Why is there a disparity between how children in care and their caregivers report mental health struggles?

A study involving 350 youth aged 11-18 in Turkish institutional care revealed that 47% of the children reported clinical-level psychological issues, whereas their caregivers identified such problems in only 15.1% of cases. Teachers identified issues in 20.5% of the students. Researchers noted that this reporting gap was most pronounced regarding anxiety, internal withdrawal, and somatic complaints—symptoms that are often less visible to external observers. Notably, despite these high rates of distress, only 2.4% of the youth had received specialized mental health services during their time in care. The primary reasons for institutional placement were family breakdown (68.9%) and poverty (15.7%), rather than orphanhood, which accounted for 31.2% of cases.

Key insights:
  • Discrepancies between youth and caregiver perceptions of mental health.
  • Analysis of mental health prevalence across five countries.
  • Impact of residential instability on child development.
  • Findings from therapeutic interview analyses.

How prevalent are mental health disorders among children in the child welfare system?

A systematic review conducted by Guillaume Bronsard and colleagues in 2016 synthesized eight studies across five Western countries, involving 3,104 children. The analysis found that 49% of children in the welfare system met the diagnostic criteria for a mental disorder, a rate approximately four times higher than that of the general youth population.

What are the psychological effects of residential instability for children in state care?

Residential changes, which often entail new schools and new caseworkers, significantly exacerbate behavioral risks. In a study of 729 children in the United States, researchers at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia found that children who remained in unstable placements over an 18-month period had a 36% probability of developing behavioral issues, compared to a 22% probability for those who were placed in permanent settings within the first 45 days. Similar trends are observed in international data, where children with multiple residential moves show higher levels of reported behavioral difficulty.

Instability extends to the professional relationships children form as well. A 2017 pilot by the Children's Commissioner for England found that in 22 local authorities, 25.2% of children changed social workers at least twice within a single year, with 10.2% experiencing three or more changes. Youth participants noted that frequent staff turnover undermines the trust necessary for effective support.

Notes and Sources

  1. Erol, N., Şimşek, Z. and Münir, K. (2010). "Mental health of adolescents reared in institutional care in Turkey: challenges and hope in the twenty-first century". European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 19(2), 113-124.
  2. Ministry of Family and Social Services (August 2026). E-Bulletin, "Child Services by the Numbers".
  3. Bronsard, G., Alessandrini, M., Fond, G., Loundou, A., Auquier, P., Tordjman, S. and Boyer, L. (2016). "The Prevalence of Mental Disorders Among Children and Adolescents in the Child Welfare System: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis". Medicine, 95(7), e2622.
  4. Rubin, D. M., O'Reilly, A. L. R., Luan, X. and Localio, A. R. (2007). "The Impact of Placement Stability on Behavioral Well-being for Children in Foster Care". Pediatrics, 119(2), 336-344.
  5. Şimşek, Z., Erol, N., Öztop, D. and Özer Özcan, Ö. (2008). "Epidemiology of emotional and behavioral problems in 6-18 year olds in institutions: a national comparative study". Turkish Journal of Psychiatry, 19(3), 235-246.
  6. Children's Commissioner for England (2017). Stability Index for Children in Care: Phase One Technical Report.
  7. United Nations (1989). Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 12.
  8. Khoury, E., Castro, N. and Incio Serra, N. (2026). "Does my voice count? Better understanding the clinical encounter in youth mental health through stimulated recall". Revue du CREMIS, 17(1).
  9. Special Commission on the Rights of the Child and Youth Protection (May 3, 2021). Establishing a benevolent society for our children and youth, final report.
  10. Ministry of Health and Social Services of Quebec (2026). Commitment to our children: Five-year progress report on the implementation of CSDEPJ recommendations.