Production company New Regency filed a federal lawsuit in Los Angeles on Friday to block filmmaker Michael Mann from reclaiming the copyright to his 1995 crime masterpiece Heat. The company is seeking a judicial declaration that the screenplay for the film, which starred Al Pacino and Robert De Niro, was a “work made for hire” and therefore ineligible for the termination rights usually granted to authors under the U.S. Copyright Act. This legal action follows three termination notices served by Mann earlier this year, through which the director sought to claw back ownership of his original writing and underlying materials, potentially stripping the studio of its rights beginning in 2028.

Why is New Regency suing Michael Mann over Heat?

New Regency initiated the lawsuit against Michael Mann to resolve what it describes as a clouding of its title to the Heat screenplay and related intellectual property. The company argues that Mann, in multiple signed agreements on behalf of himself and his loan-out companies, explicitly categorized the script as a work-made-for-hire. Under federal law, such works belong to the employer or the entity that commissioned them from the outset, meaning the creator does not have the legal standing to terminate the grant of rights after 35 years. New Regency contends that Mann’s recent attempts to reclaim the copyright threaten the company's ability to finance, license, and develop future works based on the 1995 film.

The dispute is complicated by Mann’s assertion that his rights derive from an oral agreement made in 1988 between himself and two of his own companies, MMCo. and ZZY. According to New Regency’s filing, reported by Variety and The Hollywood Reporter, Mann claimed he recently discovered this arrangement which assigned the rights to him as an independent author. New Regency’s legal team mocked this claim in court documents, likening the alleged self-negotiation to a “Shakespearean actor playing multiple parts” while speaking on his own behalf and for his corporations simultaneously. The production company maintains that Warner Bros. acquired the screenplay in 1994 under a clear work-for-hire deal, which New Regency now holds.

“After 40 years Michael Mann is exercising the right of authors to reclaim their work and in this case Michael Mann’s original creation,” a spokesperson for the director told Deadline.

How does Michael Mann justify his claim to the copyright?

Michael Mann and his legal team justify their claim to the Heat copyright by arguing that the director created the foundational characters and narrative as an independent author long before the 1995 film was produced. A spokesperson for Mann told various outlets, including TheWrap, that the filing concerns “original and personal writing” Mann conducted on various screenplays throughout the 1980s. These works eventually evolved into the iconic feature film he wrote, produced, and directed. Mann’s representatives have stated they will “vigorously defend” the lawsuit, expressing confidence that the courts will uphold the director’s statutory rights to reclaim his work.

The core of Mann's defense rests on the distinction between being an employee and being an independent author. If the court finds that the screenplay was an assignment of rights from an independent creator rather than a commissioned work-for-hire, Mann would be eligible to use Section 203 of the Copyright Act. This provision allows authors to terminate previous grants of copyright after a set period, a mechanism designed to allow creators to benefit from the long-term success of their works. Mann’s team emphasizes that he has spent four decades developing this specific creative world, starting with character work in the 1970s.

Heat (1995 film)
Heat (1995 film) (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

What is the significance of Heat in the cultural landscape?

The film at the center of this battle, Heat, is widely regarded as one of the most influential crime dramas in cinema history. Released in 1995, it was the first film to feature Robert De Niro and Al Pacino together on screen, portraying a relentless LAPD detective and a professional thief, respectively. Michael Mann’s stylized direction and the film’s grounded, technical approach to heist sequences have made it a cornerstone of the genre. Mann, a four-time Academy Award nominee known for works like The Last of the Mohicans and The Insider, further expanded this universe in 2022 by co-authoring the novel Heat 2 with Meg Gardiner.

This legal conflict arrives at a critical juncture for the franchise’s future. Mann is currently in pre-production for a film adaptation of Heat 2, which functions as both a prequel and a sequel to the original story. The upcoming project has generated significant industry buzz and is expected to explore the early years of the characters Vincent Hanna and Neil McCauley, as well as the aftermath of the 1995 film’s climax. New Regency’s lawsuit specifically mentions that certain contractual agreements with Amazon regarding Heat 2 could be impacted by the resolution of this ownership dispute.

What happens next in the legal proceedings?

The next step in the conflict between Michael Mann and New Regency involves a federal judge in Los Angeles reviewing the production company's request to declare Mann's termination notices null and void. While the litigation proceeds, Mann’s team has clarified that the lawsuit will not delay the production of the Heat 2 movie. Shooting for the sequel is scheduled to begin on January 19, 2025. It remains unclear how a potential change in copyright ownership in 2028 would affect the long-term distribution or licensing of the new film, or if the parties will reach a settlement before the case goes to trial.

Sources: This report draws on coverage by Deadline, IMDb, Variety, The Hollywood Reporter, TheWrap, Yahoo News Singapore, Cinema Express, UA.NEWS. The wording is our own.